Trevor Owens writes a cautionary tale about the David Abraham Affair where this former historian’s work was discredited due to inconsistencies in his footnotes. Owens asks “when it takes 15 seconds instead of 15 hours to fact check a source do we think historians will start to write differently, or otherwise change how they do their work?”
I don’t think so. My training in history at Carleton has instructed me to keep rough copies of my notes and be rigorous in citing references. I complete a paper with the expectation that it may be checked and also with the knowledge that the professors I am submitting work to are specialists and know the area I am writing about much better than I do. However, I do make errors and find formatting footnotes to be tedious. Much more importantly, footnotes and bibliographies are important pieces of work themselves. Using smart bibliographies as Owens recommends is not only more efficient for the historian writer, it offers the ability to share this work with others more easily.
Ian Milligan describes the impact of SSHRC’S Research Data Archiving Policy which mandates that work funded by SSHRC must be made available for use by the public who paid for it. This includes research data. This is a sensible directive given that researchers can do their work more effectively by building on the credible work of other researchers rather than starting from scratch. It also provides an overall benefit to historians. Even with the vast amount of electronic data, there is still a huge amount of information that is not available digitally. Potentially a historian’s research data may exist no where else on the Internet and making it available on-line allows other historians to use knowledge that may previously had been difficult to access. Also, as historians benefit from governments providing more Open Data, so we should reciprocate by keeping our research data open too, as long as it is ethical to do so.
In her blog entry “Generous Thinking: Introduction” Kathleen Fitzgerald notes that when universities train students to be critical thinkers, students often miss what the author they are reading is trying to communicate. More Generous Thinking is needed in order to properly study at university. Fitzgerald’s idea of Generous Thinking also applies to the unspoken contract between the Digital Historian who opens their notebook to the public and the public who reads it. By using an Open Notebook, as described by W. Caleb McDaniel, the Digital Historian benefits when a member of the public reviews their work and generously offers additional related material or alerts the historian to an error, something that would save them a great deal of time compared to finding the error during publication. However, if the public is unduly critical of the historian’s open notebook, it discourages historians from posting further work. Open Notebook history is most useful when it is part of an active project, but that also requires the most fortitude from the historian to keep it open as ideas develop and change in front of a virtual audience.
Sheila Brennan’s blog entry “My Digital Publishing Update: Nothing” describes the pitfalls of publishing a digital first project with editors used to print projects. The Digital Historian, like anyone else delivering a project, needs to be aware of the specifications of what will be produced. If the outcome of a project is to, for example, produce an article for a journal, the project should be designed to create a deliverable that matches that outcome.
One of our exercises this week was to write about a thought provoking annotation in the course readings using markdown syntax and the Dillinger.io editor – viewer. At first, I was I was not in a good mood to write and did other work. I came back to this on Saturday morning. I was fired up the about a podcast cited by @sarahmcole that described the decline in the number of women studying in Computer Science since 1984. On Saturday I also discussed the issue with my with my wife and daughter who gave me additional insight. I am glad I procrastinated so that I could consider this issue by writing about it here.
As a technical aside, I noticed that Dillinger rendered my footnotes from markdown syntax, but the .md viewer on Github did not recognize them.
It is excellent experience for our class to access a virtual machine like DHBox remotely. As more computing power and services move to the Cloud, users of data analysis tools, such as digital historians, will access these tools through virtual machines, similar to DHBox. Rather than using a computer on a desk to process data, desktop computers will increasingly be used as terminals to access virtual computers with potentially much greater processing power than what would be available on a physical computer in an office.
Git and Github
Quite a few times when I needed to download something for a computer project, I was directed to Github. I just used it as a consumer, I took the file I was looking for and left. I knew Github was used to run software projects including open-source ones, but I really had only a vague idea of how contributions to these kinds of projects were made.
I now have a better sense of Git’s function for version control and branching within a repository. I also see Git’s role in governing large projects with multiple contributors. I realize I could make a fork from someone’s repository if I wanted to work on their project independently. If my work progressed to the to the point where it was worthy of including in the original project, I see how I would make pull request to ask if my contribution could be added to the original project I had forked from.
I had wanted to test if Raspberry Pi could perform some of the things we do in this course. It runs Linux and is a low cost computer. I think it has potential to reduce barriers to people getting access to computers.
I found that Github, Slack and Hypothes.is are not supported on the versions of the Safari and Chromium web browsers I have on the Raspberry Pi (Pi for short). Some reduced functionality is available, but not enough to do real course work with these tools.
I did an experiment to see if I could connect the Raspberry Pi to Carleton University’s VPN so that I could access DHBox. I was unable to install OpenConnect, the VPN client, likely due to my lack of knowledge of OpenConnect. I was able to log in to the front page of Carleton’s VPN using the Safari web browser on the Pi. The AnyConnect software launched, but it downloaded the Windows version which does not work on the Pi.
I have stopped work on this for now.
Seeing the annotations has provided deeper insight into the readings, it is interesting to see what others in this class are thinking. The postings in Slack have also been helpful as have links to blog posts.
In the interests of practicing open notebook Digital History here is my fail log for this week. I must admit, I don’t like how its formatted.
There are many thought provoking annotations in our course this week, but it was @sarahmcole’s post in our course Slack off-topic channel that stuck with me the most. She called out how the lack of availability of computers to women affected their decisions to complete degrees in computer science, according to a documentary she cited. This resulted in a striking decline in participation by women starting in 1984, in sharp contrast to other types of degrees. The National Public Radio podcast she found describes this history and makes points I had not considered before, despite having lived though this time during high school.
My family bought the computer mentioned in podcast, the RadioShack / TRS-80 Color Computer 1, in 1983. I have a younger sister and brother, and while the computer was in various common rooms, it did become more mine. I was on it a lot. My younger sister Janelle used the computer and worked through exercises in the book “Programming with Extended Color BASIC.” but didn’t get access to it nearly as much as I did and stopped using it after the first summer we had it. Janelle now works as a detective in internet crime for the Toronto Police force and lectures and trains other police forces on technology internationally, but did not take computer science in university.
Figure 1, TRS-80 Color Computer 1 with a BASIC program.
In my high school computer classes in 1984, I remember it seemed that the people who were the most proficient with computer programming were male. While as a group we weren’t particularly smart (judging by achievement in other classes), we all had computers at home, the same advantage mentioned in the podcast. Today my daughter has her own computer, but has faced male majority/male dominated computer programming courses in high school where she has at times felt uncomfortable. Two years in a row her class debated the École Polytechnique massacre of 1989. My daughter thought this was counter to encouraging women to continue in computer science.
I asked my wife Christine Blackadar about her experience. Her family purchased a Commodore 64 in 1983 and she remembers that she and her younger brother were so excited about a game called Blue Max that they typed in the machine code for another game from a magazine article. (It didn’t work.) Christine’s experience taking computer courses in high school resembled what I had seen. There were not enough computers to go around and in a male majority class she ended up with a male partner who she described as “not scary, just very off-putting.” Her partner got much more time on the shared computer and he frequently rushed Christine to finish her work. She said the male students in her class formed a group that the male teacher catered to. Although Christine did not go on to study computer programming in university, she did become a software developer in the late 1990’s. Ultimately she chose to change careers and become a teacher. One of the things she loved during her career was to teach computer skills to her students.
Many of the pioneers of computer programming were women. My favourite is United States Navy Rear Admiral Grace Hopper. Among other achievements she is a co-developer of COBOL, a computer language still used where I work. If you use a bank, it is likely some of your financial transactions are still processed with this language. It is interesting to mark the close proximity of two events, in the NPR Podcast referenced above, 1984 was the inflection point when women’s participation rate in computer science started to decline. 1986 marked the final retirement of Grace Hopper from the United States Navy.
The preservation and sharing of artifacts using digital media.
Using computers to process, analyze and visualize data for history.
Preservation and sharing of artifacts using digital media.
The photo in Figure 1 represents a physical artifact that has been electronically copied for preservation. The photo is interesting to me not only because my grandfather is in it but also because his oxen were able to pull hard enough that the competition organizers ran out of boxed weights and supplemented them with people riding on top of the sled. This photo was stored in a detergent box of other photos with no other context or information and was at risk of being thrown away. Making a digital copy of an artifact increases the chance that a reflection of the object will survive longer in the passage of time and be available to historians. Sharing artifacts digitally offers the chance that someone else can add to the story of the artifact. Perhaps someday, a person or even a computer program will be able to tell me the exact year this photo was taken because I was able to share it with them.
Carleton University History professor Dr. Bruce Elliott has spoken about the loss of the inscriptions on thousands of marble gravestones in Philadelphia due to acidic air pollution. If the text that was on these stones was also available electronically, at least it would still be available to consult and combine it with other data.
2. Using computers to process, analyze and visualize data for history.
At the same time, the method, data and outcome of all work related to a historical inquiry should be documented in a systematic manner so that other historians can make use of the work. Other historians may repeat the research exercise and draw a new conclusion or repeat it and find flaws that when fixed provide new insights. The documentation of DH work so that it can be repeated and refined necessitates the use of same type of discipline and methods scientists use with their experiments, where even failed experiments, properly understood, can provide important discoveries and be the productive fail. Here, the Digital Historian is a scientist with data.
I was first exposed to Digital History during a lecture by Dr. Shawn Graham as part of Dr. Paul Nelles’ course on the Historian’s Craft. The lecture and assignment intrigued me both as someone returning to the academic study of history and also a user of computer technology.
I graduated from Carleton University in 1992 with a 3 year Arts degree with a major in History and I decided to return again to Carleton in the fall of 2015 in order to complete an honours year part time. Each history course I have taken has taught me a great deal, regardless of the topic. I have been looking forward to taking this course and I plan to gauge the potential for me to continue to study in this area.
As an amateur historian, I have been interested in areas that relate to Digital History. For example, I did some work on the 19th century history of the Ottawa Horticultural Society, a local gardening club. Some of this work involved scanning annual reports of the Ontario Horticultural Association over previous years and converting them to text. In the course of doing that I made copies of these reports available to other local horticultural societies here.
I would like to take my ability to gain insight by working with data much further.
My level of comfort with digital tech.
Please indulge me while I describe my first encounter with the “Information Highway”.
My first experience posting content to the web.
When I first saw the web in July 1994, I didn’t really know what I was looking at. I had a dial-up account with National Capital Freenet and was using Lynx, a text web browser where I followed links to content. I remember telling my wife that I had reached Cleveland and Florida by following these links. It was pretty neat, but I could not figure out what to do with it.
Once I saw the Mosaic browser, I was hooked and wanted to post content. I thought that the advent of World Wide Web was going to be my generation`s radio, the medium my father worked in for his career and greatly enjoyed.
One of the first web pages I made was about Ginkgo trees. This type of tree has an interesting natural history, a unique look and grows well in Ottawa. I had tried and failed to grow Ginkgoes from seed multiple times until I adapted a technique used to grow avocado pits. I wanted to tell more people about this technique, and the web was at hand. At the time I made the html page I could not find much on Internet about Ginkgoes and so I researched some of the content for the page at the Ottawa library. Here is a close to original version of the page a couple years after I first made it. When I made the page, I thought the subject might be of interest to only a few people and I stopped checking it. A few months later, I was surprised to find the page had more than 15,000 hits and numerous comments in the guestbook. Since that time, many more and much better web pages about Ginkgoes have been published. It was interesting to me to see how rapidly the new medium of the web proved to be useful for communicating with many people who shared the same niche interest.
This was a very interesting time for technology to say the least.
Generally, I am comfortable with programming, using databases, web technology and different operating systems. But I also know I have to keep renewing my skills and lots of things I was good at are now obsolete. (Does anyone need any help with Lotus Notes?)
I am interested in different kinds of history.
I just completed Dr. Joanna Dean’s course Animals in History, hence my picture of an ox team above.
The histories of Ottawa and the Ottawa Valley, southern Nova Scotia, the No. 2 Construction Battalion and Environmental History are areas I have enjoyed studying and reading about over a longer time. Recent courses about the histories of Middle East and the Inuit gave me new perspectives.
What will I get out of this course?
I know I will learn new methods to examine history. This will involve new theoretical ways to think about historical inquiry as well as the practical aspects of using data and software to look for patterns that shape a historical argument.
I know I will be challenged by the material, exercises and pace of the course. I will learn a lot from the talent of fellow students too.
I am trying to log on and do a bit of work while at an airport, but I forget some of my passwords. My current passwords are strong and different, but I did not keep note of a mnemonic for them. This reminds me of some bad habits I have had for a long time. Often when I start computer related projects I am excited and dive right in. If I take any notes at all, they are cryptic. Poor note taking may be ok when I am working on something intensely, but when I`m interrupted it`s difficult to get started again. Sometimes these projects end up abandoned. So, one of the things I hope to learn from this course is to be more disciplined with my notes related to computer projects in the same way I am much better at writing down detailed references when I am working on a paper. Taking good notes saves time. You likely already know this, I am still learning that.
This is a test post, but since I am writing this as I mop up the aftermath of my family vacation, I may have an excuse to tell you where I am. I am writing from a fairly anonymous airport hotel in Richmond, Virginia as I am waiting to fly home to my family after returning a rental car that we needed after our van`s engine died. Of course Richmond has a great deal of history, but I did not plan to be here for long.
Our original vacation plans were somewhat related to interests I have in history. I enjoy visiting the sites of early European colonization of North America and a few days ago we visited Manteo on Roanoke Island, North Carolina and saw the U.S. National Historic Site Fort Raleigh there. It is also a site of a U.S. Civil War battle and the island became a settlement for freed slaves until 1867.
We camped at Cape Henlopen, Delaware the site of Fort Miles, a World War Two defensive fortress and later a listening post to detect submarines from the U.S.S.R. during the Cold War. On the way there we dropped into the Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia. That was an interesting if somber place to see the evolution of penal practices in the United States as well as the prison`s original innovative but psychologically damaging design.
This blog will be much more concerned with digital history in future posts, but I hope I have conveyed a few of the things I am curious about.